Let SagaScope check your magic
Sign up to be notified when SagaScope can analyze your manuscript and flag inconsistencies with the magic rules defined in your Codex.
This checklist is the practical companion to the article How to create a coherent magic system (hard vs soft magic). You can keep it beside your manuscript and answer it on the fly, volume after volume.
You don't need to tick "yes" everywhere. The goal is to spot intentionally blurry areas and blurry-by-forgetfulness areas to clarify before inconsistencies pile up.
1. Origin, cost, access
- Clear origin: Do you know where magic comes from (source, entities, technology…) in your world?
- Identified cost: Have you defined at least one tangible cost for using magic (physical, mental, social, material)?
- Limited access: Is who has access (everyone, a caste, the chosen, contractors) clearly established in the text?
- Inequalities: Have you thought about how these access limits create or reinforce inequalities in society?
2. What magic can / cannot do
- Magic's domain: Can you sum up in one sentence what magic mainly does (heal, destroy, bind, transform, see)?
- 3–5 things it does very well: Have you identified 3–5 typical uses of magic that appear often in the story?
- 3–5 impossible things: Have you noted 3–5 things magic will never do, even for the most powerful?
- Use in the plot: Do these impossibilities create interesting problems to solve in other ways than magic?
3. Consequences on the world
- Medicine: Does the presence of magic have visible effects on health, longevity, death in your world?
- Transport & communication: Does it affect the speed of travel or messages?
- War and politics: Have you thought about how magic and political power interact (monopoly, regulation, bans)?
- Economy: Does magic create or destroy economic value (infinite resources, replaced labor, vanished trades)?
4. Rules, limits and exceptions
- Explicit rules: Does the reader have access to a few clear rules (even implicit at first) that recur?
- Visible limits: Do we see scenes where magic fails or can't be used, for reasons consistent with the system?
- Cost shown: Do you have at least one scene where the cost of magic is highlighted (fatigue, injury, debt, moral consequence)?
- Framed exceptions: Are any exceptions (unique ritual, legendary artifact) announced or set up in advance, and clearly costlier / riskier than normal use?
5. Integration into the plot
- No Deus ex machina: Have you avoided resolving a major conflict with a power never mentioned before?
- Foreshadowing: Have the magical abilities used at the Climax been shown in smaller form earlier?
- Magic dilemmas: Do you have at least one dilemma where using magic has as many consequences as benefits?
- Impact on arcs: Does magic play a part in characters' emotional arcs (fear of using it, addiction, rejection, fascination)?
6. Hard vs soft: clarity for the reader
- Chosen level of "hardness": Do you know whether your system is rather hard, soft or hybrid (and do you own that choice)?
- Clarity where magic solves: In moments when magic solves problems, does the reader roughly understand how and why?
- Intentionally mysterious zones: Are the most "soft" parts reserved for very high-level forces (gods, unique artifacts) and treated as myth, not as a narrative fix-all?
7. Coherence over time
- Up-to-date Codex: Do you have a place (document, tool, Codex) where your magic rules are centralized and current?
- Tracking changes: When you change a rule or magic detail along the way, do you note where and when that change occurs in the story?
- Continuity between volumes: If you're writing a saga, have you checked that characters' magical abilities don't weaken without reason or suddenly grow without learning or justification?
8. Special cases and drift
- Conscious narrative abuse: Are there places where you know you're "bending" your own rules? If so, is it owned and offset by a cost, a consequence, or a clearly stated exception?
- Effect on non-mages: Have you thought about how non-magical people live in this world (strategies, frustrations, room to maneuver)?
- Magic's symbolism: Does magic carry a theme (power, desire, faith, memory…) you can sum up in one sentence?
- Emotional role: Do you have at least one scene where magic is used in an emotional way (intimate ritual, symbolic gesture) rather than purely utilitarian?
Where does SagaScope fit in?
In SagaScope, your magic system doesn't live in an isolated document: it's integrated into the Codex, linked to scenes where magic appears, and analyzed to detect gaps between what you've defined and what you write. The long-term goal: be able to ask questions like "Show me all the scenes where my magic rules seem violated" or "Where do I forget to show the cost of magic?" and let the tool do the first pass so you can focus on author decisions. In the meantime, this checklist can already act as a guardrail, even outside SagaScope.
Keep this framework handy
Get SagaScope early access + writer templates — one email, no account required.
Ready to structure your novel?
Join the SagaScope waitlist. Founder perk: locked pricing + AI credits at launch.
SagaScope Team
The team behind SagaScope, passionate about writing and technology.
Similar articles
How to Create a Coherent Magic System (Hard vs Soft Magic)
Learn how to design a coherent magic system, whether hard (strict and codified) or soft (mysterious), without creating inconsistencies that break your novel.
The 7 sins of worldbuilding in fiction
Infodump, map before story, monoculture, missing economy: 7 classic mistakes with examples, fixes and self-diagnostic.
The Most Common Dialogue Mistakes (and How to Fix Them)
A quick list of dialogue mistakes you see everywhere—heavy exposition, interchangeable lines, clichés—with simple fixes and links to a full guide to go further.
